Written by Libby Schauer
Hi everyone,
For my blog, I decided to write back to a previous blog
titled “Who is really in charge?” by Kyle Petoskey. This is in no way intending
to be rude. I simply want to present a different side of his argument. If you
haven’t read his blog yet, I would suggest you do it quickly before you
continue on reading mine.
I am here to say that our economy needs the top 2%. Sure,
the distribution of wealth may not be even but you have to take human capital
into account as well. The high paid CEO’s of Fortune 500 companies are in that
spot because they can do what they do better than everyone else could. Back in
December my class read a chapter from the book Naked Economics titled “Why is Bill Gates so much richer than you
are”. And I found the answer; human
capital is defined as the sum total of skills embodied within an
individual: education, intelligence, charisma, creativity, work experience,
entrepreneurial vigor, even the ability to throw a fast pitch. It’s what you
would be left with if someone stripped away all of your assets-car, house,
money- basically leaving you on the street corner with just the clothes on your
back. Bill Gates is insanely rich because if that exact event were to happen to
him as what I just described, he would be snapped up in an instant by another
company. He would without a doubt have multiple companies fighting over him,
and earn back everything he lost.
I'm sure well over half of the 98% left in the country
couldn't do what the top 2% do to earn their money. They do have to work very
hard for it. Compared to the rest of the world, the United States has one of
the highest percentages of a middle class population, which is a blessing from
our economic freedoms. Instead of criticizing the upper class and wanting more
for the middle class, we should be extremely thankful we even have a middle
class, because most countries have their top 2% and the rest of the 98% are
dirt poor. The graph below shows an analysis about the distribution of wealth
around the world…
As you can see, the United States is doing enormously better
than the rest of the world, especially countries like Africa and Asia who have
a much higher population than the red, dark green, light green, dark blue and
light blue bars, thus meaning a lower standard of living.
So in summary, I submit to you that human capital is the
basis for wealth. It’s really quite simple actually; want a better paying job,
go to school and get an education to qualify for it,expand your human capital.
People working to better themselves is the only way the United States will come
closer to closing the huge margin of uneven wealth distribution. It should not
be the governments’ job to redistribute incomes. That sounds a lot like
socialism or communism, and as history has proven, those are both forms of
government that ruin a country completely. Like I said before, we should
consider ourselves lucky beyond belief to live in a country that has such a
large middle class. That is rare elsewhere.
As citizens we need to be thankful for the top 2%. There jobs are specialized and very different that what most Americans are used to. As Libby states, “I'm sure well over half of the 98% left in the country couldn't do what the top 2% do to earn their money.” Not only would they not be able to do the task they would be too lazy to put in the effort. The upper class does the near impossible jobs or the jobs that help Americans stay on track. If everyone made the same income or we had more middle class we would not have the government we do today. We need to be thankful for the upper class and if we are jealous then we should be working harder towards those jobs then.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI remember reading the Naked Economics article on Bill Gates, and it brought my thoughts back to something we don't always think of in the economy. Our own capital, or skills as an individual. We spend years of our life going to college, and all of that can go to waste if our type of human capital isn't in demand. In terms of Bill Gates, he has such a wide-variety of very in demand talents in our economy today. Not only is he a prominent business man, but he is an innovator who continues to bring about fresh ideas that help to strengthen our economy.
ReplyDeleteThrough the chart, you can notice the coorelation between the countries education systems, and their distribution of wealth. For example, in Africa- an underdeveloped nation when compared to countries such as the US and Asia- the wealth was significantly lower than the other countries. Africans aren't provided the same tools we are in the United States to expand their human capital. The graph shows how stable our standards of living are here in the United States.