It’s not up for dispute that unemployment has been in critical condition
for the past few years. With hundreds of thousands of Americans jobless,
getting people back to work was and still remains many people’s number one
priority. This task is not as simple as it sounds, as it has proven, and as a
result many of the jobs people are finding and taking are low-wage, temporary
jobs. Because the labor crisis has been occurring for such an extended period
of time, zerohedge.com is calling the shift from full-time to part-time jobs
the “New Normal”. But is this really
what America needs? The answer is no.
Now, I’m not saying that working a job that pays minimum wage while out
of work or searching for a quote on quote better job is necessarily a bad
thing. Both of my parents faced unemployment at different times in 2011 and to
help counteract that my dad worked 2 part-time jobs. The paychecks weren’t much,
but it was better than him just sitting at home and doing nothing. The key to
my dad’s story is that he worked the basic jobs he could while applying for
jobs that utilized his college degrees. And that hard work paid off, because he
now has a job that fits all of his qualifications. The problem would have been
if he accepted his “shift
from full-time to temp, or part-time labor, with virtually no contractual or
welfare benefits, and where workers are lucky to get minimum wage”. The new
focus has shifted from quality of jobs to quantity of jobs. And any economist
knows that quality is far more important than quantity (all things equal). Can
American’s live off of this new lifestyle? Again, the answer is no.
Below is
a chart that shows the enormous spike of unemployment Americans have faced since
2001.
Clearly,
something needs to be done. But not just about the quantity of jobs, but the
quantity of quality jobs. Employment spiked considerably through 2008-2009, and
has yet to drop below the 7.7%-8.0% range. Today, February 1st,
according to the Los Angeles Times
unemployment is at 7.9%, but in January of this year the economy added
157,000 jobs. So what kind of jobs were these? Taken from Zero Hedge is an
excerpt they used from the New York Times that states,
“How
did we arrive at this state of affairs? Many argue that it was the inevitable
result of macroeconomic forces — globalization, deindustrialization and
technological change — beyond our political control. Yet employers had (and
have) choices. Rather than squeezing workers, they could have invested in
workers and boosted product quality, taking what economists call the high road
toward more advanced manufacturing and skilled service work. But this hasn’t
happened. Instead, American employers have generally taken the low road:
lowering wages and cutting benefits, converting permanent employees into
part-time and contingent workers, busting unions and subcontracting and
outsourcing jobs. They have done so, in part, because of the extraordinary
evangelizing of the temp industry, which rose from humble origins to become a
global behemoth.”
Durden, Tyler. "A Quarter Of Jobs In America Pay Below The Federal Poverty Line." Zero Hedge. N.p., 30 Jan. 2013. Web. 01 Feb. 2013.
Thompson, Alasdair. "New Unemployment Figures: Good News?" Bright Green. N.p., 18 Mar. 2011. Web. 01 Feb. 2013.
Puzzanghera, Jim P February. "Economy Added 157,000 Jobs in January; Unemployment Rate up to 7.9%." Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles Times, 01 Feb. 2013. Web. 01 Feb. 2013.
I liked your point of view on how our country is adding jobs, but not always the greatest quality of jobs. My uncle has been laid off multiple times from a steel company in PA. He recently was hired by a new company and this article makes me wonder. Does his new job provide the benefits and pay of his old job as a senior worker at the factory? The chart you had was a little outdated, if you would have seen a graph up to 2013 the unemployment rate would have decreased some since the 2010 mark. The unemployment rate needs a lot of work and hopefully the country will continue to add "quality" jobs rather than the "quantity" of jobs.
ReplyDelete-Maci Woods