Is Another Stimulus Check Worth It?
Probably not. Here’s why.
Luke Tackett
Everybody knows what happened in March of this year, so I doubt it bears repeating, but here’s what happened: The COVID-19 pandemic encompassed the entire globe and devastated millions of people from all races, backgrounds, and social class, resulting in an economic decline not seen in decades. Over 50% of Americans even argue that this recession is worse than the one in 2008, according to a survey by Edelman Financial Engines (cnbc.com). Businesses were left to suffer as a result of the mass quarantining, and many people lost their jobs, raising the unemployment rate in the U.S. to a whopping 14.9%.
As a result, the U.S. government decided to pass a stimulus check in order to assist those in need. For those who don’t know, a stimulus check is a grant of money given by the government to aid people who they deem fit, generally due to a recession, depression, or overall economic decline. The stimulus package that the government sent on March 27th of this year was part of the CARES Act (Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security). It prioritized unemployed people but was also sent to many American families and small business owners. Each adult in a family received up to $1,200 depending on income and employment status, as well as $500 additional for each child under 17 years old (accounting.com).
This stimulus check cost the government around $300 billion dollars, and the total money spent on the CARES Act adds up to a whopping $2,200,000,000,000 (2.2 trillion) dollars. Keep in mind that although this act was praised and agreed upon by many politicians, every decision has a trade-off. In this case, there is a huge trade-off, due to the immense scope of the proposal. Yes, some families all across America have benefited greatly from this “free money,” but as we know, there is no such thing as free money. This money is coming directly from the government, which means only one thing: the national debt increases yet again. According to Rob Berger, an advisor contributor on Forbes, the U.S. spent a total of over $6.5 trillion dollars in the last fiscal year (ending September 30th), a third of that coming from the CARES Act alone. Looking at the chart below (provided by Visualcapitalist.com), it’s easy to see the immense impact that this expenditure had on the debt. Compared to 2019, the debt increased by approximately 25%.
What’s even worse is that the money spent on the CARES Act doesn’t contribute to the GDP because stimulus checks are a transfer payment, and no goods or services are being produced in the process. This means the GDP drops while the debt increases, which is a horrible outcome, and right now it is the worst debt-to-GDP ratio the U.S. has ever seen. Due to this, many Americans worry if receiving these stimulus checks is really worth it.
Congressional leaders are planning to release another round of stimulus checks that are part of a relief package worth $900 billion. Supposedly, the agreement should be completed by the end of this week (12/19/20) according to The Washington Post. It will aim to help small businesses and unemployed Americans, similar to the last one. People will receive $600-$700 dollars if they lie below a certain income threshold.
Many people complain that the money from the first stimulus check was not enough to support them for any significant length of time, so considering this check will give half that amount of money, it’s not likely that this will make much of a difference. One reader on Marketwatch.com says, “As a married person with 5 kids and a mother that lives with us, I think $150,000 is too low. Kids are expensive and they eat a lot, not to mention medical and dental bills, especially now that school is out.” People are also upset that their cost of living does not play a part in the amount of money they receive, since different states have vastly different economies. On top of that, but there are still lots of undocumented workers who are not eligible to receive these benefits because they’re immigrants and not U.S. citizens.
In the end, the CARES packages may have helped some American families, but not enough are truly satisfied with its results. Throwing money at people isn’t going to help eliminate poverty because it’s not being received by the right people, or the people who are receiving it aren’t benefiting to any significant degree. The trade-off of having the national debt increase by trillions of dollars isn’t worth it. If the government continues to spend this much money on things like the CARES packages, the likeliness that this already unpayable debt will get paid off will only decrease.
Works Cited
Berger, Rob. “5 Breathtaking Numbers Reveal The Unsettling Cost Of Stimulus.” Forbes, Forbes Magazine, 18 Oct. 2020, www.forbes.com/sites/robertberger/2020/10/18/5-big-numbers-reveal-the-unsettling-scope-of-stimulus-spending/?sh=57c612e142b7.
Bernard, Tara Siegel, and Ron Lieber. “F.A.Q. on Stimulus Checks, Unemployment and the Coronavirus Plan.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 26 Mar. 2020, www.nytimes.com/article/coronavirus-stimulus-package-questions-answers.html.
“Coronavirus Stimulus Package of 2020.” Accounting.com, 18 Sept. 2020, www.accounting.com/resources/stimulus-package-2020/.
Jeff Stein, Mike DeBonis. “Congressional Leaders Add Stimulus Checks to $900 Billion Relief Package as They near Deal.” The Washington Post, WP Company, 16 Dec. 2020, www.washingtonpost.com/us-policy/2020/12/16/congress-stimulus-checks-relief/.
Lu, Marcus. “Charting America's Debt: $27 Trillion and Counting.” Visual Capitalist, 30 Oct. 2020, www.visualcapitalist.com/americas-debt-27-trillion-and-counting/.
MFoxCNBC. “The Covid Pandemic Is Worse than 2008 Crisis for a Majority of Americans, Study Says.” CNBC, CNBC, 1 Dec. 2020, www.cnbc.com/2020/11/10/pandemic-worse-than-2008-for-a-majority-of-americans-study-says.html.
“U.S. Department of the Treasury.” The CARES Act Provides Assistance to Workers and Their Families | U.S. Department of the Treasury, 14 Dec. 2020, home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/cares/assistance-for-american-workers-and-families.